Totally Greenwashed: Green Planet Bottle

“Green Planet Bottle” has become a substitute for consumers of the plastic bottle water since 2009. This product is labeled as organic, 100% plant-based, petroleum-and BPA-free, and carbon neutral. It is not only healthy for consumers, but also has positive impact on our environment. It sounds like the days of plastic water bottle made from petroleum are gone. However, I wonder how “green” or sustainable these green planet bottles can truly be?

According to the fact sheet of Pacific Institute, the process of bottling water produces more than 2.5 million tons of carbon dioxide and it takes 3 liters of water to produce 1 liter of bottled water. Transporting bottled water also requires millions in barrels of oil. Not only the waste is produced, but the time it takes to break down is also significant. It just doesn’t worth it.

Throughout Green Planet website, I could not see anything about the company itself but just the product. It has a very simple and basic bare bone format with hardly any information about their practices such as actual production process and transportation system of the bottle. They claim that their product is sustainable comparing to “old school bottled water”. Their bottle is not like those made from crude oil that could cause over filling of landfills and harmful greenhouse gases. Without leaching harmful chemical, it is safe to reuse. But in fact,a compostable bottled water is still bottled water. It is the same thing with only different packaging and marketing campaign. When it comes down to it, bottle water will never be as good for the environment.

In Annie Leonard’s YouTube video, she states clearly that bottled water is actually trashing our environment all around the world. Even the plastic bottle water labeled as recycling, it is still not fully recycled. Some of them will slate to be down cycled or end up in the landfill. Therefore, this company obviously involves greenwashing component. They are definitely trying to take advantage of the good intentions of consumers who wish to protect the planet. They are misleading them about the real face of their product.

Totally Greenwashed: The Body Shop

I love The Body Shop. Their products always smell good and my skin feels good when I use them. They claim that their products are all “natural”. Through their website, icons and slogans of world- protection can be found such as “support community trading”, “against animal testing”, “protect our planet”, “defend human rights” and “activate self-esteem”.

The website is currently promoting a kind of body lotion called 100% biodegradable shower gel. They emphasize that it meets the eco-conscious standard. Its ingredients are not only non-toxic to aquatic organisms, but also able to minimize packaging waste. In other words, this product is to help protecting our environment.

However, a media controversy about The Body Shop was held after being taken over by L’Oreal in 2006. It was disclosed that L’Oreal often tests their products on animal before selling to the public. This goes against the core value of The Body Shop – “against animal testing”. Although L’Oreal tried to address the problem through the media, boycotts by customers still emerge around the globe. (wikipedia)

In 2009, Guardian.co.uk wrote an article to criticize The Body Shop. It states,

“Daabon Organics, a Colombian firm that provides the British chain with 90% of all its palm oil, was part of a consortium that asked the courts to remove farmers from a sprawling ranch 320km north of the capital Bogotá with a plan to grow African palm. Police in riot gear evicted the farmers in July.” “Some locals had lived and worked on the land for more than 10 years and had already applied for the right to own it under Colombian law before the consortium bought it.”

This actually confounds The Body Shop because it has a strong commercial relationship with Daabon: 7.5 million bars of soap made from Daabon’s oil are produced every year. It once again violates the core values of The Body Shop – “support community trading” and “defend human rights”. By 2010, The Body Shop wrote on its website that they attempt to use wood from responsibly managed sources, certified by the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) if it is possible. Is The Body Shop really taking action on this claim? At this point, I could not see any action being taken yet.

Although there are many “green” information appeared on its website, The Body Shop does not clarify how green their products really are. By labeling as “Natural”, “Organic”, or “Eco-conscious”, it gives the impression to consumers that their products are made from natural ingredients. But in fact, these labels are meaningless without elaboration. Besides, The Body Shop has its own eco-conscious standard symbol which looks more trustworthy at first glance. With this symbol, their products are urged to meet non-toxic, strict biodegradability standard, and limit packaging waste. The truth is that this eco-conscious standard does not comply with the international standard, and it is not supporting by any certification. It is just the standard of The Body Shop itself. This symbol is misleading people who desire to save the planet. Therefore, I consider that The Body Shop has been practicing greenwashing.

To be a smart consumer, you may want to read “Seven Sins of Greenwashing”.

Good: Seventh Generation

Seventh Generation is a brand that I would want more people to consider. It is a company that sells all sorts of products from household cleaners, paper towels, laundry detergent, baby products, to toilet paper. They are very transparent when it comes to their business practices and about what goes into their products. Its mission was stated very clearly on their webpage,

“To inspire a more conscious and sustainable world by being an authentic force for positive change. “ “From the very beginning, we have pushed to have a real impact on our competitors, suppliers, communities, and government. Products maybe the vehicle, but far reaching, genuine change is the mission.” Seven generation sustainability is an ecological concept that urges the current generation of humans to live sustainably and work for the benefit of the seventh generation into the future.”

To make sure every decision they make can benefit the next seven generations, they are inspired by part of the Great Law of the Iroquois Confederacy,

“In our deliberation, we must consider the impact of our business affects both our environment and the environment of future generations.”

On every product, every single ingredient and material safety data (current product formulas) are listed. Also, there are tips on all product packages to advise consumers,  for instance, "Did you know? Each refill pack uses 90% less packaging than a hard plastic container. Please reuse our Baby Wipes container."

After reading more about them, I would say they are more of a social group making environmental changes through their brand.